Sibling Rivalry

HOW MEXICO AND THE U.S. BUILT THE MOST CONTENTIOUS, CO-DEPENDENT FEUD IN WORLD SOCCER

SIBLING RIVALRY


HOW MEXICO AND THE U.S. BUILT THE MOST CONTENTIOUS, CO-DEPENDENT FEUD IN WORLD SOCCER

Author Home2025-12-17T20:50:19+00:00


THE UNITED STATES and MEXICO are bound together by history, culture and geography. Whether they want to be or not. Their ongoing family drama is more evidence that rivalry is a uniquely compelling form of intimacy. In “Sibling Rivalry,” Hal Phillips investigates the fluid, centuries-old associations between the two nations, on field and off. He explores the byzantine border dynamics, their economic and cultural anxieties, and the North American Derby’s stunning evolution from a one-sided nothing-burger to an intensely contested, ever-escalating blood feud. The partisans are front and center here, but Phillips also draws on the personal narratives of transnational players and fans, breathing more life and nuance into this thoroughly North American story.

San Zusi, the North American Derby's 21st-century Patron Saint. Click above to learn more about Graham's Canonization.

FIFA Introduces New ‘Dynamism’ to World Cup Ticketing Grift

The bleak, hyper-lux reality of World Cup ticket pricing is beginning to sink into the global futbol consciousness, and with FIFA itself. How do we know the latter? Because FIFA president Gianni Infantino sounds in increasingly defensive, claiming that without extortionate 2026 tournament revenues, “There would be no football in 150 countries in the world. There is football because, and thanks to, these revenues we generate with, and from, the World Cup, which we reinvest all over the world,” he told the World Sports Summit in Dubai the last week in December. For the U.S. audience, this recalls big-time college sports apologists who claim that without D1 football and men’s basketball programs earning gobs of TV money, things like varsity field hockey or tennis programs would go away. Forgetting that they somehow managed to exist without said revenue streams since the 1950s. While one struggles to imagine how these 150 footballing nations have managed to operate up to now (!), there does remains a ray of hope for U.S.-based fans, even as 2026 [...]

Excerpt, Chapter 9: The Continuing Education of Rafa Marquez

Rafa Marquez is a thoroughly modern figure. In the twenty-first century, no one has wielded more influence on the fortunes and reputations of Mexican soccer. The modern game is a global game, so it follows that Rafa made much of his mark, for himself and his countrymen, abroad. In 1999, he left the security of domestic futbol for the French club AS Monaco. Following the World Cup trauma of 2002, he moved to F.C. Barcelona, where the polished center back appeared 243 times for one of history’s finest club sides. To the extent that Mexican players have taken their talents abroad, Hugo Sanchez and Marquez are the models. Manchester United star Javier “Chicharito” Hernández, in particular has cited Marquez as his inspiration in this regard. Not every foreign adventure went to plan. After an unhappy two-year stint in MLS, with New York Red Bulls—the worst decision of his career, he later told ESPN Deportes—Rafa returned home to finish his playing days where they started, with Atlas of Guadalajara. While his resume is among [...]

January 1, 2026|

‘What the rivalry means on both sides of the border’

“Hal Phillips examines how the rivalry grew from the heartland of Ohio to Mexico City’s Estadio Azteca, and what the rivalry means on both sides of the border: the shame of Mexicans, the insecurities on both sides, the envy and scorn the two opponents feel about each other in one of international soccer’s most unique and surely complicated rivalries. Really interesting book. Phillips gives also us an important history lesson, not just on the USA-Mexico soccer rivalry and the evolution of the sport in both countries, but on the interdependence between neighboring nations.”

— Paul Kennedy, Editor in Chief, Soccer America magazine

‘Top-Notch Storytelling’

“Starting with Seamus Malin’s terrific Intro, Hal Philllps’ take on the complex U.S.-Mexico soccer rivalry is nuanced, layered, and deeply felt. Top-notch storytelling for anyone interested in understanding what is really going on beneath the surface whenever the U.S. Men line up against El Tri.”

— Ty Keough, USMNT veteran and Mexican American

a masterpiece in the cultural sociology of rivalries in sports and beyond.’

I cannot find the proper words of praise and delight that I felt having read in one fell swoop Hal Phillips’s magisterial work on the US – MEXICO rivalry in soccer. This is not only a masterpiece in the cultural sociology of rivalries in sports and beyond; but it also features a nuanced command of all things soccer (and sports) deeply ensconced in the larger histories of Mexico and the United States with sumptuous detours into Britain, the Continent and Latin America. This is a remarkable book!

— Andrei Markovits

Author of Offside: Soccer and American Exceptionalism; the 2022 memoir, The Passport as Home: Comfort in Rootlessness; and new from Dickinson-Moses Press, Women in American Soccer and European Football: Different Roads to Shared Glory. 

‘A history more complex than participants and supporters can imagine’

“Back in the day, when we were trying to convince editors about a growing audience for soccer, Hal Phillips’ generation came along to back us up. Then, they started carrying the ball — playing the game at a decent level and, now, telling the tales. This is a story that touches home, taking us to origins that predate the first U.S.-Mexico encounter, in 1934, and outlining a history more complex than participants and supporters can imagine.  This book untangles the complexities and explains how, despite a clash of cultures, the U.S. and Mexico appear to be finding common ground. Surprisingly, considering most soccer rivalries are eternal, Phillips reveals this one could be headed in an unexpected direction leading up to the 2026 World Cup, and beyond.”

— Frank Dell'Apa, Longtime Boston Globe soccer columnist
Go to Top